Adam Hendry Opposes Settlement Sending $4.29 Million in Cheyenne River Ranch Sale Money to FC Sioux Falls

Partial docket for Adam Hendry personal bankruptcy

Update(Nov. 13): Judge Mora continued the hearing on the plan administrator’s motion to Dec. 9 at 10 a.m. Eastern, according to a court notice filed Friday. The notice does not give a reason. No order has been entered on the motion.

West Palm Beach FL –Adam Hendry wants the judge to stop a settlement that would send most of the $4.4 million from the sale of his Cheyenne River Ranch to FC Sioux Falls Pref, LP. In a filing Tuesday, he argues the deal gives him no credit against the roughly $11.8 million judgment he owes Alejandro Arguelles, and that FC Sioux Falls has not shown it is owed the money at all.

Hendry’s attorney, Thomas Zeichman, asks Judge Mindy A. Mora to deny the payout or keep the money in escrow “pending an evidentiary hearing.”

Mora is set to take up the settlement Friday, Nov. 13, at 11 a.m. Eastern by video conference. The court’s notice calls it a non-evidentiary hearing and sets aside ten minutes.

The deal Hendry is fighting

As the Sentinel reported earlier this month, plan administrator Daniel Stermer asked the court on Nov. 2 to lift the injunction that has frozen $4,384,338.70 from the ranch sale and to pay it out: $91,932.77 to three Cheyenne River Ranch creditors and $4,292,405.93 to FC Sioux Falls.

The payout implements a settlement between FC Sioux Falls and Arguelles and his company, Gatoralex Consulting, LLC, which all three signed Oct. 27.

Under it, FC Sioux Falls would pay Arguelles and Gatoralex $2.65 million for a $2.65 million share of the Arguelles judgment, which the agreement puts at $11,773,735 as of Oct. 18.

The agreement says the payout is not a payment on that judgment, so the amount Hendry owes would not change.

What Hendry argues

The judgment doesn’t shrink. Hendry’s filing says the settlement “denies credit against the Arguelles claim.”

By his math, FC Sioux Falls would keep $1,642,405.93 in cash and hold a purchased piece of the judgment, while “no distribution reduces that judgment.” He argues that leaving the full claim outstanding “may require payment from other Plan sources and reduce funds available to junior creditors.”

Under his confirmed plan, he says, ranch proceeds go first to BankWest, then to Arguelles and Gatoralex as Class 2 creditors, then to unsecured creditors. FC Sioux Falls is not in that order. Arguelles and Gatoralex, whose place in line Hendry’s filing defends, are themselves parties to the settlement.

FC Sioux Falls hasn’t proved its claim. The plan administrator’s motion says FC Sioux Falls asserts it is owed more than $5 million by Cheyenne River Ranch.

Hendry says no court has fixed that amount or its right to this money, and he demands “an itemized accounting” of principal, interest, fees and payments. “Every dollar which does not go to Arguelles is harmful to the estate,” his filing says.

“No new consideration.” FC Sioux Falls’s claim to the ranch money rests on an April 7, 2025, Payment Agreement signed by Cheyenne River Ranch and the Shalom on the Range Trust, which followed FC Sioux Falls’s 2022 investment in a Hendry company.

Hendry argues, as Cheyenne and the Trust did in their Oct. 7 motion to dismiss, that a later promise to cover an earlier debt needs new consideration under Florida law.

His filing says FC Sioux Falls “provided no new consideration for Cheyenne’s and the Trust’s 2025 undertaking” and describes the Payment Agreement as one “which lacks consideration.” This time he makes the argument in his own name, as a reason to hold the money.

Other claims on the money. Hendry and Cheyenne River Ranch originally asked that about $2.5 million in other payables be paid first.

Stermer’s motion says he verified only the $91,932.77 and has “not seen any documentation other than intercompany bookkeeping entries” showing that Community Credit Union of Florida is a legitimate creditor of the ranch or entitled to a $1,351,895.55 payment tied to L’Chaim Farm, LLC, a Hendry affiliate.

Hendry replies that the credit union or L’Chaim “provided traceable value and funds to Cheyenne,” and he asks the court to set aside reserves for those claims.

His filing agrees with Stermer that about $1.352 million of L’Chaim loan money went to BankWest to pay down Cheyenne’s debt.

The process. Hendry says the settlement’s form of assignment, which the agreement calls Exhibit A, is not attached to the motion and should be filed before approval. The 20-page filing the Sentinel reviewed ends at the signature pages without it.

He also notes that bankruptcy rules generally call for 21 days’ notice of a settlement unless the court directs otherwise for cause. The hearing is 11 days after the motion was filed. The settling parties’ Nov. 15 deadline, he says, does not “establish a threat to funds already held in trust.”

If no order is entered by then, either FC Sioux Falls or Arguelles and Gatoralex can cancel the agreement.

A promise Hendry’s filing doesn’t mention

Hendry is also a party to FC Sioux Falls’s April 7, 2025, Forbearance Agreement, signed three weeks before he filed for bankruptcy.

Section 4(f) requires him to cooperate with FC Sioux Falls and take actions it reasonably requires to support its position that money owed on the Arguelles judgment is subordinate to the amounts owed to FC Sioux Falls under its investment documents.

Hendry’s lawyers have described that clause themselves. In the Oct. 7 motion to dismiss, they wrote that Section 4(f) “obligates Hendry to support Plaintiff’s assertion of priority.”

Tuesday’s filing does not mention Section 4(f). It targets the separate Payment Agreement, which Hendry did not sign.

The Oct. 7 motion also did not challenge Count 5 of FC Sioux Falls’s lawsuit, which alleges Hendry breached his guaranty and the Forbearance Agreement and seeks a ruling that the debt survives his bankruptcy. The settlement does not release that claim.

What happens next

As of Thursday evening, Hendry’s opposition was the latest entry on the docket. It showed no reply from Stermer, FC Sioux Falls, or Arguelles and Gatoralex, and no order moving the hearing.

If Mora approves the payout, FC Sioux Falls would dismiss Counts 1 through 3 of its adversary case, including its request to revoke the plan’s confirmation, within seven days after the order becomes final. Counts 4 and 5 would continue against Hendry, Cheyenne River Ranch and the Trust.

FC Sioux Falls has until Nov. 27 to respond to the Oct. 7 motion to dismiss or amend its complaint, and a scheduling conference is set for Dec. 9 at 10 a.m.

The Sentinel will report any ruling once a written order is entered.

Previous Reporting

Settlement Would Send $4.29 Million From Cheyenne River Ranch Sale to FC Sioux Falls, Not Arguelles


Sourcing

This report is based on:

  • PACER docket, In re Adam Hendry, Case No. 25-14711-MAM, U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Southern District of Florida (docket viewed Nov. 12, 2026):
    • Doc. 626: Plan Administrator’s Expedited Supplemental Motion to Lift Injunction and Authorize Certain Distributions, with Exhibit 1 (Settlement Agreement), filed 11/2/26
    • Doc. 627: Notice of Hearing, Nov. 13, 2026, 11:00 a.m., filed 11/2/26
    • Doc. 628: Certificate of Service, filed 11/3/26
    • Doc. 629: Debtor Adam Hendry’s Response in Opposition, filed 11/10/26
    • Doc. 624: Order on Motion to Approve Certain Distributions, entered 9/25/26
    • Doc. 605-4: Forbearance Agreement, April 7, 2025, § 4(f)
  • PACER docket, FC Sioux Falls Pref, LP v. Hendry, et al., Adv. Proc. No. 26-01285-MAM:
    • Doc. 28: Order Granting Motion for Preliminary Injunction, 9/25/26
    • Doc. 37: Joint Motion to Dismiss Complaint in Part, filed 10/7/26
    • Doc. 50: Order Granting Plaintiff’s Agreed Motion to Extend Deadline to Respond to Motion to Dismiss, entered 10/30/26
    • Doc. 53: Order Setting Scheduling Conference and Establishing Procedures and Deadlines, entered 11/2/26
  • Hendry’s characterizations of the settlement are his own; the Sentinel checked them against the settlement as filed. Allegations about FC Sioux Falls’s rights under the 2025 agreements come from its filings and the settlement’s recitals, which Arguelles and Gatoralex expressly do not admit.
  • Times are Eastern, as stated by the court. The notice gives the hearing time as 11:00 a.m. without naming a time zone.

Discover more from THE RAPID CITY SENTINEL

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.