The Ben French deal: What the public record shows about Black Hills’ bitcoin-mining power contract

close up photo of gold coins
Photo by Bastian Riccardi on Pexels.com

Rapid City SD – On Dec. 23, 2025, a Black Hills Power executive signed a contract to power “data mining and processing equipment” on Rapid City’s northwest side. One week earlier, the land under that equipment had changed hands for $950,000.

Nearly 11 months later, the contract is still waiting for approval from the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission.

Most of it is still sealed, and Black Hills has asked regulators to keep it confidential “forever.” Meanwhile, the company on the other side of the deal, CleanSpark, has been describing the site to its investors since February.

This explainer lays out what the public record shows about the deal, filed as PUC docket EL26-008, and what it still doesn’t say.

The customer and the land

Black Hills’ application names the customer as CSRE Properties South Dakota, LLC, a South Dakota limited liability company. Its listed principal place of business is 490 Deadwood Ave.

Pennington County property records show CSRE Properties South Dakota as the owner of that parcel. It covers 7.76 acres in the area the county calls “Sturgis Road Industrial,” with the land assessed at $929,600.

The county lists a sale on Dec. 16, 2025, for $950,000. That was land only, by special warranty deed, and the sale is marked “not open market.” The owner’s mailing address is 10624 S. Eastern Ave. in Henderson, Nev.

The parcel’s permit history includes a 2015 permit to demolish cooling towers. It sits in the same quarter-quarter section as a 40-acre Black Hills Power property next door at 409 Deadwood Ave., the company’s Rapid City service center.

Black Hills’ 2026–2035 Energy Facility Plan, filed in July, places its Ben French site along Deadwood Avenue and says the company plans to retire the Ben French generating units in 2027.

In its rate case, Black Hills said it expects demolition bids in late 2026 for decommissioning in 2027. That testimony doesn’t say what happens to the land or the substation afterward.

Who is behind CSRE

South Dakota Secretary of State filings tie the customer to CleanSpark, Inc., a Nasdaq-listed bitcoin miner headquartered in Henderson.

  • CSRE Properties South Dakota was organized on Dec. 9, 2024, by Leighton R. Koehler, who signed as general counsel. Its office is listed at 10624 S. Eastern Ave., Suite A-638, Henderson, the same street address the county has on file for the land. CleanSpark’s annual report to the SEC says its corporate headquarters is in Henderson.
  • The company’s 2025 annual report, signed Dec. 1, 2025, about two weeks before the land purchase, lists four managers: Koehler, Gary A. Vecchiarelli, Brian J. Carson and CleanSpark, Inc. All four list the Henderson address.
  • Koehler also organized a second company at the same address that day, CleanSpark SD, LLC. The state certified it seven minutes before CSRE. Both companies list the same three original managers: Zachary Bradford, Gary Vecchiarelli and Natasha Betancourt.

CleanSpark Wyoming

Black Hills already serves CleanSpark in Wyoming. Its Cheyenne utility, Cheyenne Light, holds a blockchain power agreement with a sister company, CSRE Properties Wyoming, LLC, for a site near Cheyenne’s East Business Park substation.

The Wyoming deal followed a similar path. According to the Wyoming Public Service Commission’s Aug. 14, 2025, order, the original agreement took effect July 25, 2024, but wasn’t filed with regulators until April 28, 2025, about nine months later.

An amended and restated version took effect Jan. 27, 2025, and was filed April 29, 2025, a day after the original. The order gives no reason for the amendment.

Wyoming regulators kept the agreement confidential and accepted it at a July 24, 2025, meeting. April 28, 2025, is also the day Black Hills applied for its South Dakota blockchain tariff. Black Hills’ data-center website names CleanSpark as a Cheyenne customer and says the company has served Wyoming’s blockchain industry under a similar tariff for more than six years.

The same website lists Rapid City among the locations Black Hills is marketing to data centers.

What CleanSpark has told investors

CleanSpark’s filings don’t name Rapid City or the address, but they describe a site that matches.

  • Its 2026 quarterly reports to the Securities and Exchange Commission say the company “acquired property in South Dakota” in December 2025 “with intentions to build out infrastructure.”
  • On the company’s Feb. 5, 2026, earnings call, an executive described “a 15-megawatt site in South Dakota.” The executive said the local utility had introduced a blockchain-specific interruptible tariff that gives the company the “lowest cost per kilowatt hour of almost any site in our portfolio.”
  • CleanSpark’s August 2026 investor presentation lists South Dakota at 15 contracted megawatts.

The February call came six weeks before Black Hills filed the contract with the PUC and asked that it be kept confidential in its entirety.

In the same filings, CleanSpark now describes itself as a data center developer, “until recently focused exclusively on bitcoin mining,” that is building for both bitcoin mining and artificial intelligence workloads.

There has been no joint public announcement. The contract bars either side from making one without the other’s written approval.

What the contract says

For five months the public couldn’t see any of the agreement. When Black Hills filed it on March 19, 2026, the PUC docket lists only a confidential copy, marked “not available to the public.”

On Aug. 19, Black Hills filed an amended version along with the first redacted copy the public could see. The cover letter gave no reason for the amendment.

The public version blanks out the customer’s name, the property address, the amount of power, the length of the contract, pricing, the security deposit and several deadlines. Some of what remains:

  • The location. The “Facility” is the customer’s “data mining and processing equipment” to be installed “in the vicinity of Company’s Ben French substation in Rapid City.” The definition covers “all expansions, modifications, and additions” during the contract term.
  • The land deal. Section 2.3 says the contract doesn’t take effect until a “real estate transaction contemplated by the purchase and sale agreement between BCIS Customer and Company” closes. “Company” is Black Hills Power. It also says that closing is itself conditioned on the power contract taking effect. If the land deal didn’t close by June 30, 2026, the contract would end automatically. An earlier section describes the property as the one “on which the Facility will be located.”
  • The tariff. The contract says service will be under Black Hills’ “proposed” blockchain tariff, “subject to approval” by the PUC.
  • Confidentiality. The parties’ dealings are governed by a nondisclosure agreement dated May 29, 2024, more than 18 months before the contract was signed.
  • Filing and approval. Black Hills agreed to file the contract with the PUC “within sixty (60) days following the Effective Date,” defined as the date of the last signature. Both sides agreed to “support and defend” the contract at the PUC. Either side can walk away if the commission rejects it or attaches conditions it won’t accept.
  • Pricing. An attached exhibit shows the price structure as the cost of supply plus a margin markup. The figures are blacked out.
  • Deadlines and security. The customer can be found in default for failing to reach commercial operation, or a minimum level of demand, by deadlines that are redacted. It must keep payment security in place, such as a letter of credit renewed in terms of at least 360 days.
  • Signatures. The customer’s chief executive signed at 11:10 a.m. Pacific time on Dec. 23, 2025. Marne Jones, Black Hills’ senior vice president and chief utility officer, signed at 12:03 p.m.

Black Hills Application

Black Hills’ application, signed by regulatory manager Jason Keil, summarizes more.

The customer can be cut off for up to 300 hours a year, and during system emergencies.

It pays for the energy, transmission, ancillary services, reserves and related charges it uses.

Black Hills owns and maintains the lines on its side of the meter, and the customer reimburses the cost, including a federal income tax gross-up.

The application asked the commission to approve the contract by June 1, 2026. It doesn’t mention the land condition.

Black Hills’ March 19 cover letter asked that the “Confidential BCIS Agreement” be kept secret “in its entirety” and “treated as confidential forever.” It cited state rules covering trade secrets and confidential commercial information.

The tariff behind it

The contract depends on a rate schedule Black Hills asked for on April 28, 2025, in PUC docket EL25-019.

The commission’s Jan. 27, 2026, agenda described it as a tariff for interruptible loads of 10 megawatts or more, intended “for new blockchain customers.”

The agenda also said losses from that service would not be recovered from other retail customers.

Black Hills first proposed it under a different name, the “Economic Flexible Load Service” tariff. In written answers to PUC staff, dated May 2025 but not posted to the docket until Jan. 22, 2026, the company said the tariff was not limited to cryptocurrency miners. It said it expected large manufacturing and industrial users. In those answers, the company also said:

  • it would buy power for these customers only from wholesale markets, not from its own power plants;
  • it could cut off the customers’ power without any action on their part, on no more than 15 minutes’ notice;
  • its example calculations assumed two 25-megawatt customers.

Black Hills also sent staff a draft customer agreement, which is confidential.

Black Hills and PUC staff settled the case in a stipulation dated Jan. 20, 2026. The settlement:

  • renamed the tariff the Blockchain Interruptible Service Tariff;
  • required Black Hills to file each blockchain contract for commission approval;
  • kept those customers’ sales, revenues and costs out of earnings reports and future rate cases;
  • barred Black Hills from passing a blockchain customer’s unpaid debts on to other South Dakota customers;
  • set contract terms at two to five years, with prices renegotiated at least every three years.

A share of the margin from blockchain customers is credited back to other customers through Black Hills’ transmission cost adjustment. The formula for that margin is in a confidential part of the settlement.

The commission approved the settlement on Jan. 27, 2026. Commissioner Kristie Fiegen dissented, according to the commission’s written order.

The tariff took effect Jan. 29, 2026, five weeks after the CSRE contract was signed.

Black Hills explains the tariff on a page of its website. There it says the tariff was approved “after months of review” and that any customer served under it “will not impact customer rates.” The page also answers “No” to whether the new Lange II generating plant is being built to serve blockchain and data center businesses. It says Lange II will replace the Ben French generators, which are scheduled for decommissioning in 2027.

Where it stands

The EL26-008 docket is still listed as pending. As of this writing, no orders have been issued and the case has not appeared on a commission agenda. PUC staff analyst Joseph Rezac and staff attorney Jennie Fuerst are assigned. Staff sent Black Hills data requests on March 25 and May 20. The docket shows only certificates saying the requests were sent. Neither the questions nor Black Hills’ answers are posted. Residents have filed public comments in the docket in April, August and November.

South Dakota’s rules give people who aren’t parties to a docket a way to ask for the release of information filed as confidential. When someone asks, the commission must rule on whether the material qualifies. At its Nov. 4 meeting, the commission took up a request of this kind involving three other dockets.

The blockchain tariff is designed to keep the mining customer’s costs out of Black Hills’ other rate cases. Two of those are moving now. On Nov. 4, the PUC approved a settlement in Black Hills’ general rate case that adds $27.4 million a year in revenue, about $16 a month for a typical residential customer, starting in December. Black Hills had asked for $50.6 million.

A separate request to recover the cost of the Lange II gas plant in Rapid City is still pending. As filed, it would add $39.5 million a year, about $19.70 a month for a typical household.

Why it matters now

The contract has surfaced as Rapid City argues over how, and whether, to regulate data centers.

Ordinance 6746, the city’s proposed data center rules, has been continued to January 2027. On Nov. 12, Mayor Jason Salamun said two options are on the table: a six-month moratorium on data center development, or interim guardrails while permanent rules are finished. He has said he prefers the guardrails, calling a moratorium “kicking the can down the road.”

The draft ordinance uses 50 megawatts as the line between a “large-scale” data center, allowed as a conditional use, and a hyperscale facility. CleanSpark has told investors its South Dakota site is 15 megawatts.

That leaves a question no public document answers yet: would a pause or new guardrails reach a project where the land has already been bought and the power contract already signed, but the contract itself is still waiting on state approval?

What the record doesn’t say

  • Who sold 490 Deadwood Ave.? The contract says the customer and Black Hills Power had a purchase-and-sale agreement for the facility’s land. The county record doesn’t name the seller in its summary. Black Hills Power’s 2025 annual report to federal regulators shows two related entries for that year. The company retired $106,445 in land from the plant category that includes the Ben French units, and it booked $1.17 million in gains on property sales. The report doesn’t identify the properties.
  • Why does the timing run backward? The contract says the land closing was conditioned on the power contract, yet the county lists the sale a week before the contract was signed.
  • Why was it filed 86 days after signing, when the contract calls for filing within 60 days of the Effective Date?
  • Is it really 15 MW? CleanSpark’s investor materials say 15 MW for South Dakota. The figure in the contract filed with the PUC is blacked out, so the public can’t check that the two match.
  • Why did a public version appear in August, and did the confidential terms change too?
  • What about the June dates? The requested approval date of June 1 and the land-closing deadline of June 30 have both passed while the docket stays open.
  • Where is it in the 10-year plan? Black Hills’ 2026–2035 Energy Facility Plan, filed with the PUC on July 1, never uses the words “blockchain,” “data center” or “interruptible.” It doesn’t say whether the 15 MW customer is included in its load forecasts.
  • Why keep it secret “forever” when CleanSpark was already describing the site, its size and its power price advantage to investors?

The Sentinel sent questions to Black Hills Energy and CleanSpark on Nov. 14. This story will be updated with any response and as records come in.


Sourcing


Discover more from THE RAPID CITY SENTINEL

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Comments

One response to “The Ben French deal: What the public record shows about Black Hills’ bitcoin-mining power contract”

  1. Scott Eccarius Avatar
    Scott Eccarius

    The lack of transparency surrounding this issue is breathtaking. When the Catalyst TIF was being recommended in August 2025, this 15MW data center project was euphemistically referred to in Catalyst Phase II as a “Significant Industrial Client” and that the TIF ‘facilitates utility upgrades for a $400 million private development [which] creates high-paying jobs with community-wide multiplier effects [and] generates stable new sales tax revenue. This is all outline in this staff report dated August 21, 2025: https://www.rcgov.org/index.php?option=com_docman&view=download&alias=35229-25ti018-staff-report&category_slug=08-august-planning-9&Itemid=149

    Furthermore, the use of the euphemism “Significant Industrial Client,” should have never been allowed for this, then undisclosed, bitcoin mining data center in the Catalyst TIF application. In fact, Section 5 of Rapid City’s Application For Tax Increment Financing states: “The applicant shall identify all persons and entities that have an interest in the project and/or in the entity applying for the tax increment financing district. The disclosures shall require identification of all members of an LLC or LLP, other partners, investors, shareholders and directors of a corporation or any other person who has a financial interest in the project or in the entity applying for the tax increment financing. This provision requires identification of all persons who have an interest in the project, including those whose interest exists through, an LLC, LLP, corporation (whether as a director or shareholder) or other legal entity. The applicant shall be under a continuing obligation to update this disclosure within thirty (30) days of any changes throughout the application process and throughout the life of the developer’s agreement. City’s own TIF.”

Leave a Reply