
Rapid City SD – On Thursday evening, the Chick-fil-A drive-thru line at I-90 and LaCrosse Street stretched onto Eglin Street, past the Longhorn Steakhouse.
Rapid City police posted an update telling drivers to expect delays, “even in the westbound lane” of Eglin. A community service officer’s pickup sat in the photo.
The restaurant sits on land inside Tax Increment Financing District #99, the Marshall Heights Tract.
The council approved that district 8-2 on Aug. 4, 2025.
On paper, it’s a district for four fast-food restaurants and a tire shop.
The city’s own records show it’s also a way for the city to repay itself, with 7% interest, for a police precinct it had already agreed to buy with cash. It also reimburses the developer for a turn lane the city already required it to build. And it sits over land where an earlier TIF district closed out 11 months before this one was approved.
What the council approved
The Planning Commission was given two versions of the plan on July 24, 2025.
Option 1 totaled $8,785,842.
Option 2 expanded the district. It added undeveloped land behind the N. LaCrosse Walmart, right-of-way to extend Luna Avenue north to Latrobe Avenue, and a traffic signal at Luna and Eglin. That raised the total to $10,061,666.
The commission recommended Option 2, 6-3, on both the district and the plan. Commissioners Erik Braun, Alicia Ginsberg and Mike Quasney voted no.
The council approved the plan “as submitted by the Rapid City Planning Commission.” Council members Bill Evans and Rod Pettigrew voted no on both resolutions.
The city’s agenda page for the item still lists the Option 1 totals. The signed developer’s contract and the city’s own 2025 TIF valuation sheet both use the Option 2 figures.
Here is how the $10,061,666 breaks down:
- The developer, AMM Rapid City LLC: $2,750,000 in capital costs, plus $2,069,487 in interest at 7.5%. Total: $4,819,487.
- The City of Rapid City: $1,750,000 in capital costs, plus $3,452,179 in interest at 7%. Total: $5,202,179.
- Administrative fees: $25,000 to the city and $15,000 to the county.
The city’s interest is nearly double its principal.
That’s because the developer is paid first. The city’s balance sits and grows until about year 13. Then the city collects through year 20, with the final payment due by Dec. 1, 2045.
Whose taxes
A TIF district doesn’t get a check from anyone.
It keeps the new property taxes that come from rising values inside the district, the “increment,” and uses them to pay back project costs.
Those taxes would otherwise go to the school district, Pennington County and the city.
The project plan’s own table shows how the expected $10.85 million in increment splits:
- About $6.51 million from the school district’s share
- About $2.57 million from the county
- About $1.75 million from the city
Because this is classified as an economic development district, state aid holds the school district harmless. The staff report says the difference is “made up across the entirety of the State of South Dakota.”
The application was sent to the county commission, the county director of equalization, the school superintendent and the school board president.
All four are listed as “No Comment provided.”
The precinct the city had already bought
The city’s share of the TIF is mostly a police station.
Of the city’s $1,750,000, $1,150,000 is for “real property assembly”: partially funding the purchase of 120 Knollwood Dr. and its improvements as the RCPD North Precinct.
The TIF staff report, dated July 24, 2025, says:
“This purchase would not be possible without the use of TIFD.”
The city’s own records tell a different story.
On April 16, 2025, the Legal and Finance Committee took up buying 120 Knollwood for a north precinct. The agenda item listed the funding as “Not Budgeted.” The council authorized the mayor and finance director to sign the purchase agreement April 21.
The purchase agreement, signed by Mayor Jason Salamun and attested by Finance Director Daniel Ainslie, shows:
- Price: $1,800,000, cash. The city put down $180,000 in earnest money, with the balance due at closing by certified funds.
- No financing contingency.
- No appraisal requirement. The offer is not subject to the property appraising at the purchase price.
- Inspections waived: “All inspections have been completed; any other inspections of physical condition are waived.”
- Closing set for on or before June 9, 2025. The city could extend 60 days by adding $100,000 more in earnest money. The earnest money was nonrefundable and would be released to the seller June 9 if closing was extended.
- The seller, CW Properties LLC, could keep using the building rent-free until Aug. 31, 2025.
CW Properties had owned and occupied the building since 2005. The county’s sales history shows the property last sold in September 2005 for $800,000. State records show the company filed to terminate in December 2025, saying its business had been wound up.
The county assessed the property at $953,700 in 2025.
The city paid about 1.9 times that.
The city signed that cash agreement two months before AMM Rapid City filed its TIF application on June 24, 2025.
The deed transferring 120 Knollwood to the city was recorded Aug. 18, 2025, two weeks after the council approved the TIF.
The renovation contract, awarded Sept. 8, 2026, to RCS Construction for $1,294,000, is paid from CIP funds ($400,000) and the police general fund ($894,000).
There is no TIF money in it.
The TIF doesn’t pay for the precinct now. It pays the city back later. Under the plan’s own schedule, that doesn’t start until roughly year 13. When it does start, it carries 7% interest.
Purchase plus renovation comes to at least $3,094,000.
The boundary
To include the precinct, the district had to reach it.
The Option 2 map runs from the LaCrosse restaurant site west along a narrow strip on E. Knollwood Drive. That strip includes city land rezoned to Public in 2024 for Knollwood Park. It ends at the precinct parcel near N. Maple Avenue.
Park land is tax-exempt. It produces no increment.
According to the Planning Commission minutes, commissioners asked about “Knollwood Park area’s inclusion in the district, but not in development.”
The turn lane
The district repays the developer for a northbound right-turn lane on N. LaCrosse into the site.
It’s in the signed developer’s contract, Exhibit A: “N. LaCrosse St. turn lane.” According to the minutes, Tax Increment Finance Planner Mike Dugan listed it among the developer’s TIF costs at the Planning Commission meeting.
That turn lane was already required.
The same morning, the commission approved AMM’s subdivision plan on its consent agenda, 9-0. The council later approved it 9-1, with Pettigrew voting no.
That approval requires the developer to build the turn lane recommended in its traffic study (stipulation 5) and to dedicate the right-of-way for it (stipulation 6), unless the city grants an exception.
The same traffic study also recommended a westbound right-turn lane on Eglin at Rapp Street.
The subdivision staff report says Public Works “administratively waived” it. “No improvements to Eglin Street are required as part of this plat.”
According to the minutes, Development Project Engineer Manager Todd Peckosh told commissioners that the area intersections “currently all of them meet requirements.”
On Thursday, police were warning drivers about delays in Eglin’s westbound lane.
The “blighted” hotel
The developer’s case for TIF calls the site long-neglected, underutilized and blighted.
The developer’s contract with the city repeats it. It says the property “has long suffered from functional obsolescence and blight.” Dugan called it “a long neglected area,” according to the minutes.
What was there:
- A city memo from October 2025 describes the property as developed with “a hotel, an office building, and two motels.”
- In 2016, the Planning Commission approved an overlay allowing a conference room and liquor sales at the hotel. That year the owner pulled a $1.14 million permit for restrooms and a conference/ballroom.
- The county’s permit history shows a renovation completion check on Jan. 11, 2023.
- The county assessed the site at $10,435,400 for 2025, including $8,665,100 in buildings. That’s up from $7,616,600 the year before.
AMM’s application lists a $7,500,000 lot purchase.
County sales records show two warranty deeds on the property five days apart:
- $4,000,000 on Oct. 3, 2025
- $7,500,000 on Oct. 8, 2025
The county records list AMM Rapid City LLC as the current owner. They also show a $4,000,000 contract-for-deed sale in May 2020.
The TIF staff report gives the lot an “anticipated assessed value of $7,548,700.”
That number doesn’t match any year in the county’s assessment history.
Who’s behind it
AMM Rapid City LLC was formed in Michigan on April 15, 2025.
Its address is 30200 Telegraph Road, Suite 205, in Bingham Farms, Mich. Its 2026 South Dakota annual report lists Gabriel Schuchman as beneficial owner.
At the Planning Commission, according to the minutes, Dugan said “AMM Rapid City is a new entity of parent company, Alrig USA.”
The site engineering plans are filed under the project name “ALRIG USA – 1902 N LACROSSE STREET.”
The paper trail starts before the company existed:
- March 13, 2025: The city did a “courtesy review” of the proposed lot lines, according to the developer’s site plan.
- April 2, 2025: A Rapid City firm completed the land survey.
- April 15, 2025: AMM Rapid City LLC is formed in Michigan.
- April 16, 2025: Pre-application meeting with city staff.
- June 24, 2025: TIF application filed.
- Aug. 4, 2025: Council approves the TIF, 8-2.
- Aug. 14, 2025: AMM registers to do business in South Dakota.
- Sept. 24, 2025: Schuchman signs the TIF contract for AMM. Its opening recital says the developer “owns” the property.
- Oct. 8, 2025: The city signs. The $7.5 million deed is recorded the same day.
The developer’s TIF payments won’t go to AMM.
On Oct. 29, 2025, Legal and Finance took up an assignment agreement. Under it, the city pays AMM’s share of the increment directly to BCL-CRE 3 LLC, an Illinois company in Northbrook, until AMM’s loan is paid. The city’s 2025 TIF valuation sheet lists BCL-CRE 3 LLC as the district’s financial institution, at 7.5%.
That’s the maximum rate the contract allows.
Federal bankruptcy court records show that in June 2026, two San Antonio companies in a Chapter 11 case asked a judge in the Northern District of Texas for an emergency order extending the bankruptcy stay against BCL-CRE 3 LLC. The court put that case on hold Aug. 25, 2026.
The case doesn’t involve Rapid City or AMM.
The TIF that came before
This isn’t the first TIF on this ground.
Tax Increment District #56, “Rushmore Crossing,” was created in November 2005. The city lists its applicants as Mid Atlantic and KDRK Properties (Kevin Buntrock, Rich Huffman, Hani Shafai and Don Ward). Its original legal description included the same hotel lot.
Its plan was revised three times by August 2007. The final version planned about $20.4 million in costs and interest, including:
- Rebuilding Farnwood/Eglin Street
- Traffic signals
- A detention dam
- $1.887 million in right-of-way
- A north-south street the third revision names outright: Luna Avenue, from Eglin south to Anamosa
That plan projected the district paid off by June 2017, with the Luna phase by June 2018.
The council dissolved TID #56 on Sept. 3, 2024, on its consent agenda, 9-0, without discussion.
The resolution says only that “there are no longer any reimbursable project costs remaining to be paid.” It gives no payoff date or total.
Eleven months later, the council created District #99.
District #99’s legal description includes “Tract G Revised Rushmore Crossing Subdivision.” That’s former TID #56 territory. The new district pays to extend the same street, Luna Avenue, north from Eglin.
Where it stands
The city’s 2025 TIF valuation sheet shows District #99 with a certified base value of $27,626,100. That’s $2,425,300 more than the project plan expected.
Its current value is $24,449,806.
That’s $3,176,294 below the base.
With the hotel gone, the 1902 N. LaCrosse lot dropped from $10,435,400 to $1,943,000 in assessed value. For now, there’s no increment to pay anyone.
The developer’s contract gives AMM until Dec. 31, 2030 to finish the TIF improvements, and until Dec. 31, 2032 to get certificates of occupancy for every building.
What’s still unanswered
- If the city signed a $1.8 million cash purchase in April 2025, why did the staff report say the purchase “would not be possible without the use of TIFD”?
- Why does the city charge its own project 7% interest, and why was the city put last in line?
- Why did the city pay about 1.9 times assessed value for 120 Knollwood without an appraisal?
- Why is a turn lane the developer was already required to build listed as a TIF cost?
- Public Works waived the Eglin turn lane. Who signed off, and on what basis?
- Was the LaCrosse turn lane built? Is the Luna and Eglin signal, called “the highest priority” in the plan, up?
- How does a hotel property the county valued at $10.4 million qualify as blighted?
- Where did the staff report’s $7,548,700 figure come from?
- Why did the developer’s capital request grow from $2,000,000 in the application to $2,750,000 in the staff report?
- TID #56 was projected to be paid off by 2018. Why did it stay open until September 2024, and what was the final payoff?
- Why was Knollwood Park drawn into the district?
Sourcing
This story is based on public records:
- City of Rapid City: TIF staff report 25TI010 (July 24, 2025); project plan, Option 2; TIF application 25TI009-10; district maps; subdivision staff report and attachments 25PL050; staff memo 25PD029; rezoning report 24RZ004; Legal and Finance item LF041625-06 and the RCPD purchase agreement for 120 Knollwood Dr.; LF102925-10 assignment agreement and the TIF District #99 developer’s contract; CC090826-02.3 bid documents; “Rapid City Taxable Valuation, 2025 pay 2026”; the city’s Tax Increment District History page; TID #56 project plan and three revisions (2006–2007)
- Official minutes: Planning Commission, July 24, 2025; City Council, Aug. 4, 2025, and Sept. 3, 2024
- Pennington County Director of Equalization: property records for 1902 N. LaCrosse St. and 120 Knollwood Dr.
- South Dakota Secretary of State: AMM Rapid City LLC filings; CW Properties, LLC filings, including its December 2025 articles of termination
- Rapid City Police Department Facebook post (Nov. 19, 2026)
- U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Northern District of Texas: public docket, Adv. No. 9:26-ap-09005
Leave a Reply