
Rapid City SD- Rapid City’s planned 2027 water rate increases are getting a second look.
At its Monday, Nov. 16 meeting, the City Council unanimously directed staff to review the increases and report back in 30 days on whether pausing them makes sense.
Over the nearly two-hour meeting, council also overturned a $1,254.53 utility bill in a 5–4 revote and pushed the OneHeart lease agreement to Dec. 2.
Then it heard more than an hour of public comment, most of it urging a 12-month data center moratorium. Council could not act on any of it Monday night.
Nine council members were present: Laura Armstrong, Josh Biberdorf, Bill Evans, Kevin Maher, Callie Meyer, John B. Roberts, Lindsey Seachris, Greg Strommen and Council President Stephen Tamang. Council member Lance Lehmann was absent.
Water Rate Review Ordered (Item 20)
Seachris pulled Resolution 2026-087, the 2027 fee schedule amendments, from the consent calendar.
She moved to approve it with an amendment directing staff to “review water rates in light of the studies currently underway and report back to council on whether pausing water rate increases for the coming year would be prudent.” It passed unanimously.
Seachris said several things warrant “a fresh look at the assumptions behind our planned water rate increases”:
- A consultant study approved Monday will look at whether the Mountain View water treatment facility can be rehabilitated. That could offer an alternative to the anticipated $180 million east treatment facility that was part of the case for the rate increases when they were approved.
- About $7 million in reservoir savings tied to approval of the East Transportation District. She asked staff to clarify how those savings relate to costs the TIF district will now cover.
- Savings from the Public Works maintenance facility, a separate $80 million item that was also part of the original justification for the increases.
“I just think right now, with our families facing ever-increasing rates, the cost of groceries, and now the Black Hills Energy rate increase, it would be a really great time for us to identify any savings,” Seachris said.
Finance Director Daniel Ainslie said a full picture depends on two answers still several months away: whether Mountain View can be fully refurbished or the east-side plant will be built, and the impact of consolidating the Public Works maintenance facility.
Staff can “probably” provide an updated report within 30 days, he said, but “please note that that would be preliminary.” Seachris asked that the item come back to council in 30 days.
Community Enrichment Moves to Finance (Item 36)
On second reading, council approved Ordinance 6758 by voice vote. It amends Title 2 of the municipal code to move the Community Enrichment Division into the Department of Finance.
Seachris made the motion and Biberdorf seconded.
Evans asked where the idea came from and what the benefits would be. He questioned whether Finance had the expertise for the work:
“I’m trying to figure exactly why the Finance Department would have the expertise to be determining what the city in particular should be doing in terms of any kind of community enrichment, or things we need to be adding or subtracting from what we offer to the citizens.”
Ainslie said then-Mayor Steve Allender asked him to take on the division when he was about three weeks into the job. Because Community Enrichment works closely with the Grants Division, the move made sense, he said.
The division has been joined with Finance, working alongside the Grants Division, “for three and a half years,” Ainslie said.
He also said Finance has shifted how it spends federal Community Development Block Grant money:
“Anytime we’re using HUD dollars we have to go through a litany of different federal requirements, and that has been something that unfortunately has really eroded away the purchasing power of this. And so now we are trying to use the funds to do large capital projects—that way the purchasing power is still very valid, versus doing a lot of small projects where each project has to have an environmental review, has to have [Buy American], has to have Davis-Bacon wage requirements, other things like that.”
Ainslie said the city still gathers community input on needs. The latest session was about two months ago, he said, and requests far outstripped the available money.
Evans said he wouldn’t oppose the move but remained unconvinced:
“Well, I guess I don’t know enough about that particular process to be opposed to it, but it just seems to me that it’s a little mixing of duties that maybe shouldn’t be mixed. I mean, the financing of things is certainly something to me totally separate than the concepts being originated as to what the citizens bring to us, you know, as council members, or to an independent thing that’s maybe in Community Development or wherever this would be. So I guess we’ll see how it works. I’m just still a little confused as to how that’s going to work out in the future.”
Seachris urged staff to lean on the Black Hills Council of Local Governments for help with federal reporting rather than limiting how CDBG money is used. She noted the city pays the council $40,000 a year in dues.
Disputed Utility Bill Waived 5–4 (Item 38)
Council voted 5–4 to waive $1,254.53 in utility charges billed to Kevin Eagle Tail at 807 Silver Street. It took two votes to get there.
The Public Works Committee had recommended waiving the charges in a 3–2 vote on Nov. 10.
Speaking for her father during public comment on agenda items, his daughter told council he was neither the owner nor a tenant of the property.
She said city records showed conflicting start dates for the account. She also noted that the city had no call recording showing the account was ever set up.
Public Works Director Mike Theis confirmed that no recording exists.
He said staff had already removed the December through February charges, which brought the bill down from $1,924.92 to $1,254.53.
A motion to deny the appeal was worded as a double negative, and the confusion that followed forced a revote. Meyer then made a substitute motion to waive the charges, and it passed.
- Yes: Strommen, Armstrong, Tamang, Evans, Meyer
- No: Maher, Roberts, Seachris, Biberdorf
OneHeart Lease Continued to Dec. 2 (Item 47)
Council pulled Resolution 2026-085, the OneHeart lease agreement, from the consent public hearing items. It continued the item to the Dec. 2 Legal & Finance Committee meeting.
During the hearing, OneHeart Chief of Operations and Programming Chadrick Ratigan addressed what he called inaccurate information from public comment at the Nov. 10 Legal & Finance Committee meeting.
“Speaking confidently about these systems is not the same as understanding them,” Ratigan said.
He described OneHeart as an independent nonprofit running a clean and sober campus, not a place where people are simply dropped off:
“OneHeart is not a detox center, a sobering center, or an overnight drop-off location for law enforcement. … There’s an entire referral process, there’s a screening process that includes [pre-intake] review of program expectations, we do drug testing, additional screenings, and any guest who’s referred has to work with a partner for at least 30 days before we’ll meet with them.”
Ratigan said that in six and a half years at OneHeart, he has never known anyone to arrive intoxicated and simply be admitted.
Once participants are enrolled, alcohol, illegal drugs and other intoxicants are prohibited. “Participants cannot remain on campus if they ever come back impaired, and when that happens, our procedures provide options, and that does include walking someone over to Care Campus to Safe Beds—that is one of the options when appropriate,” Ratigan said.
OneHeart works closely with Rapid City police and fire and the Department of Corrections, he said, but each side keeps its own role. “OneHeart doesn’t get to decide who gets cited, charged, or arrested—that’s what law enforcement does. And law enforcement doesn’t decide who gets admitted to OneHeart—we do.”
Data Centers: A Push, But No Vote
Data centers drew the most speakers of the night. Nothing moved.
Items raised during general public comment cannot be acted on unless the council members present unanimously vote to place them on the agenda, so no data center vote was possible Monday.
Speakers instead pressed council to act before two dates already on the calendar:
- Nov. 25: a Planning Commission review of a moratorium.
- Jan. 21, 2027: the delayed hearing on Ordinance 6746, the city’s proposed data center rules.
Justin Huntley was the city’s floodplain manager until Nov. 13. He also ran its air quality and MS4 stormwater programs, and his work there included the data center ordinance.
He asked council to “listen to the people” and not to wait:
“We worked on the data center ordinance. A lot of people put a lot of time into that, and then by delaying that ordinance, you’re leaving the window open for things to happen that nobody in this city wants. And I would just ask that you immediately either approve the ordinance as written and amend it as needed, or apply the moratorium as soon as possible.”
Former council member Ron Sasso went further. He handed out a rough outline of an ordinance that would prohibit data centers outright.
Sasso said he expects the current path to end in a referendum that voters reject: a moratorium, more revisions, the ordinance coming forward, and residents voting it down.
Until then, he said, city staff time is being wasted, “which happens to be our money.” He added that it isn’t fair to the developer to be left in limbo either.
He asked council to use the unanimous-consent rule to add a prohibition ordinance to Monday’s agenda, then direct staff to draft one.
“State law says we have the right to ban data centers. That’s within our right as a municipality, and so to me that is something we should do,” Sasso said.
No council member made either motion.
At least six other residents called for a moratorium of at least 12 months, double the proposed six-month window, or for a permanent ban. One backed demands made at a Nov. 13 press conference.
Another resident spoke directly to members of the Elevate Rapid City board. He asked whether they would be open to an enforceable Community Benefit Agreement for any data center, rather than letting one build by right under zoning rules alone.
He said he had taken the city’s data center survey and found its power, water and noise figures unrealistic, including noise ratings under 40 decibels, which he called impossible. If a data center were held to those figures with oversight for non-compliance, he said, it would fail immediately.
He also asked whether rural residents and ranchers understand what 40 to 80 decibels of noise means, or how much water data centers use. And he asked whether “the people who voted for you” want a data center in Rapid City.
Other Public Comment
- SBA disaster loans: Daniel Beaulieu, a public affairs specialist with the U.S. Small Business Administration’s Office of Disaster Recovery, said Nov. 30 is the deadline for physical disaster loans. The loans stem from a Sept. 1 presidential declaration for severe storms and flooding, mainly in the Oglala Lakota area. It covers the Oglala Sioux Tribe’s reservation and the counties next to it, Pennington included. Homeowners and renters can borrow at rates as low as 2.875%, and businesses and private nonprofits as low as 4%. Applicants can get in-person help at SBA centers in Oglala and Pine Ridge, or apply online at lending.sba.gov.
- Transit: A resident called for more RapidRide funding, better driver pay and digital fare cards.
- Nuisance liens: Two residents asked the city to remove three nuisance liens on an 11th Street property. Mayor Jason Salamun referred the request to Community Development Director Vicki Fisher.
Executive Session
Council met in executive session for 26 minutes after public comment.
The published agenda listed the session under SDCL 1-25-2(3), which allows council to consult with legal counsel about proposed or pending litigation or contractual matters.
Neither the mayor nor any council member said on the record why the session was being held, either going in or coming out.
When council returned, it voted to leave executive session and moved straight to the bill lists. No action was taken on anything discussed in the session.
Council Action & Vote Summary
Items 2–35 (except 20) — Consent Calendar
Approved unanimously (voice vote)
Item 20 — Res. 2026-087: 2027 Fee Schedule + 30-day water rate review
Approved unanimously (voice vote)
Item 36 — Ord. 6758 (2nd Reading): Move Community Enrichment to Finance
Approved (voice vote)
Item 37 — Countryside Blvd. Sidewalk Variance: Renner Associates / JBK Farms LLC
Approved 7–2 (Nay: Tamang, Meyer; Lehmann absent)
Item 38 — Utility Appeal: Kevin Eagle Tail (807 Silver St., $1,254.53)
Waived 5–4 (substitute motion by Meyer)
Items 39–41 — Subdivision Plans: Park Hill #7, Commerce Park, Apple Valley
Approved with stipulations
Item 42 — 2027 Alcohol Beverage License Renewals
Approved (voice vote)
Items 43–46 — Consent Public Hearing Items
Approved (voice vote)
Item 47 — Res. 2026-085: OneHeart Lease Agreement
Continued to Dec. 2 Legal & Finance
Item 48 — Ord. 6755 (2nd Reading): Rezone 2918 Garden Ln. (LDR-1 to Mobile Home)
Approved (voice vote)
Item 49 — Ord. 6756 (2nd Reading): Rezone Homestead St. & Elk Vale Rd. (GC to LI)
Approved (voice vote)
Item 50 — Bill List: Main Street Square / Visit Rapid City ($336,370.84)
Approved (Meyer, who works for Visit Rapid City, abstained)
Item 51 — Bill List: Remaining City Bills ($9,776,483.83)
Approved (voice vote)
What’s Still Open
Will staff’s 30-day report recommend pausing the 2027 water increases, even though final consultant numbers are months away?
Will the Planning Commission move on a moratorium Nov. 25, or will the city wait for Ordinance 6746 in January?
And what will Legal & Finance do with the OneHeart lease on Dec. 2?
Sourcing
This recap is based on the City of Rapid City’s YouTube livestream of the Nov. 16, 2026 City Council meeting (“Rapid City City Council 11-16-2026”) and the published meeting agenda.
Leave a Reply