Following the increment: How two Rapid City TIF districts are built to pay for themselves

“Rapid City’s active tax increment districts, including #86 (Black Hills Industrial Center), #101 (Catalyst District) and #77 (Black Hills Energy). Map: City of Rapid City

Rapid City SD – Page 8 of an August 2025 city staff report lists six assumptions behind an $84 million financing plan. Assumption No. 4 reads: “Black Hills Energy increment is $1,700,000 per year.”

The report says Black Hills supplied that figure, calculated for “a power plant facility,” but it doesn’t name the plant.

The district’s boundary includes the land where Black Hills Energy is building Lange II, its new natural gas generating station on Deadwood Avenue.

Under the plan, the new property taxes from that power plant project won’t flow to city, county and school budgets the usual way. They’re projected to help repay road work, utility lines and $30 million toward an indoor sports fieldhouse, all inside a single tax district.

That arrangement is tax increment financing, or TIF. Rapid City has used it since 1983, and it is central to two developments the Sentinel has examined this month: the Black Hills Industrial Center on the south edge of town, and the Ben French and Lange II power questions on the northwest side, covered in the Ben French deal.

This explainer walks through how TIF works, using the actual paperwork for two districts. Every figure comes from public records.

How a TIF works, in five terms

The district. The city draws a boundary around a set of parcels. State law requires a finding that at least 25% of the land is “blighted,” or that at least half of it will promote industrial, commercial or other economic development, and that improving the area is likely to raise the value of substantially all other property in the district.

The base. On the day the district is created, the state certifies the total assessed value of everything inside it. That number is the base. Taxes on the base keep going to the city, the county and other taxing bodies as usual.

The increment. As land inside the district is developed and its value rises above the base, the property taxes on that added value, the increment, are set aside in a separate TIF fund.

The project costs. That fund repays the things listed in the district’s project plan: roads, water and sewer lines, grading, and the interest on the money borrowed to build them. State law lists the eligible categories, and the city’s TIF policy narrows them further.

The payoff. When the project costs are repaid, the district closes. From then on, all taxes on the higher value go to the regular taxing bodies.

Three more pieces matter:

  • Classification. A TIF district is classified as Local, Industrial, Economic Development or Affordable Housing. The state’s school-funding formula keeps the school district whole either way, but the classification decides who covers the gap.
  • In a “Local” district, property owners inside the district make it up. In the other classifications, it’s made up statewide.
  • Both districts in this explainer are Economic Development districts.
  • Overlap. Districts can stack on the same land. When they do, the older district is paid first.
  • The 2017 project plan for District #80, Promise Road, put it plainly: because the new district overlaid District #70, “all incremental revenues generated within the proposed district are allocated to the TID 70 expenditures until fully repaid.”
  • Under the city’s 2026 policy, new districts can’t overlap existing ones without a joint city-county resolution.
  • The cap. State law limits all TIF districts in a city to 10% of the city’s total assessed value. A June 2026 staff report put Rapid City at 2.20%.
  • “That figure counts the district’s current value; the city’s 2025 summary, which counts only base values, puts it at 2.10%.”

District #86: A developer’s TIF

Black Hills Industrial Center Tax Increment District No. 86 was created by the City Council on May 16, 2022, and took effect June 10, 2022, according to the city’s developer agreement.

The applicant was Black Hills Industrial Center, LLC. Its April 2022 application lists Hani Shafai as the only member. Dream Design International was the engineer.

The size and the base. The district covers about 912 acres south of Catron Boulevard and east of Highway 79.

When it was proposed, the staff report put the land’s 2022 assessed value at $1,050,700. The base the state later certified was lower still: $343,700, according to the city’s 2025 TIF summary. Most of it was undeveloped.

The application said the property was zoned for general agriculture and “generates very limited real estate taxes.”

The price tag. The plan has three phases with a combined TIF cost of $78,099,446:

  • Phase I: $23,582,626, including $6.5 million in grading, $2.6 million for a rail line and switches, and $1.7 million for Old Folsom Road
  • Phase II: $24,233,154, including $5.3 million for Aesir Boulevard
  • Phase III: $30,283,666, including $5.8 million in off-site water main and a $3.64 million booster station

About $34.8 million of that total is projected interest. The application estimated 6% and said the rate wouldn’t exceed 9%. The developer agreement the council later approved caps reimbursable interest at 7%, and only for interest actually paid to a lender.

What it promised. The application projected more than $500 million in development, more than 2,000 full-time jobs with an annual payroll above $120 million, and more than $5 million a year in property taxes at full build-out. The anchor tenant named at the time was AEsir Technologies’ battery plant. The city’s TIF committee found the proposal conformed to city TIF policy.

What staff flagged. The April 2022 staff report is a good example of how to read one of these documents. It noted that:

  • The total rose from about $46 million to about $78 million between the TIF committee’s first review and the Planning Commission. About $20 million of the increase came from financing, professional fees and contingencies.
  • The applicant added $90 million in projected development value between versions. In staff’s words: “Without this added valuation figure, the District would not pay off based on the projections from the original application.”
  • The rail lines and switches would be “privately owned infrastructure by the developer,” to be used “solely by the development and not the community at large.”
  • The request covered “not oversizing, but all of the typical developer costs for streets, utilities, and grading.” City policy normally treats oversizing, the cost of building bigger than one project needs, as the TIF-eligible piece.
  • Of the $78 million, about $11 million could be considered costs the city would eventually have paid anyway: water mains, a drainage pond, a traffic signal and the booster station.

The “but-for” test. A TIF is supposed to pay only for development that wouldn’t happen “but for” the TIF. The developer’s own pro forma showed a 6.12% return on Phase I without the TIF and 7.5% with it. For Phase II, it projected a loss of more than $21 million without the TIF.

Who carries the risk. The developer agreement is where a TIF’s fine print lives. District #86’s says:

  • The developer pays for the work up front and is reimbursed only from the increment the district actually produces. If the increment falls short, the developer absorbs the loss. The agreement says the city’s obligation “does not constitute a general indebtedness of the City.”
  • Reimbursement covers only actual, certified costs for improvements listed in the project plan and built inside the district’s boundaries.
  • The work must follow state competitive-bidding laws, because it is paid back with public money.
  • The city may dissolve the district if none of the improvements has been accepted, or put under contract, by Dec. 31, 2027.
  • The plan can be revised, but total project costs can’t exceed $105,434,252.10, which is 135% of the original $78.1 million.

The 2025 revision. The council approved Amendment #1 to the project plan on Sept. 2, 2025. The amendment says it adds “no additional money” and cuts total TIF costs by $5,199,433.60. It also:

  • removes Aesir Boulevard, because the state Department of Transportation wouldn’t allow a traffic signal where it would meet Highway 79. The city needs a signal at the landfill intersection, and the state wouldn’t allow two;
  • adds $3,530,186 for Capacitor Boulevard to reach the land Aesir Boulevard was meant to serve;
  • moves the rail line and switches out of Phase I, saying they “are not needed now until Phase II and less rail will be required”;
  • trims Phase I from $23,582,626 to $23,388,789, Phase II from $24,233,154 to $23,547,557.40, and Phase III from $30,283,666 to $25,963,666, for a new total of $72,900,012.40;
  • cuts off-site water main work across all three phases from $6.6 million to about $2.69 million. The biggest piece removed is Phase III’s $5.8 million for the regional water main from 5th Street, one of the items the 2022 staff report counted among likely eventual city costs. The $3.64 million booster station stays;
  • cuts rail work overall from $3.8 million to $1.8 million;
  • leaves projected financing costs unchanged at $34,797,746, even though capital costs went down.

The amendment’s updated projection, supplied by the developer, covers Phase I. It expects 11 new commercial buildings by 2028 and $88,750,000 in new taxable value from 2028 on, enough to repay the district by 2042, its final year. The original 2022 plan had projected $135 million in new value by 2026 and $500 million by 2042.

When land inside a district goes back to farm value. The Sentinel reported this week that two Black Hills Industrial Center parcels, 301.95 acres in all, are now assessed as agricultural land. Only one of them is inside District #86:

  • Tax ID 72927, 191.95 acres: inside. Its legal description falls within the district’s boundary, the north half of Section 29 east of Highway 79, and its county card lists a TID exemption. Its assessed value went from $2,176,700 in 2024 to $85,200 in 2025 and $74,300 in 2026.
  • Tax ID 73237, 110 acres: outside. It sits in the section’s southeast quarter, and its card shows no TID exemption.

Here’s why that matters. Increment is figured across the whole district: the total current value of everything inside it, minus the total certified base. One parcel losing value doesn’t cut the increment by itself. It pulls the district total down, and growth on other parcels can make up for it.

In this case, the city’s summary shows District #86’s total value fell from $5,555,097 to $5,252,961 across the same two assessments, against a certified base of $343,700.

That puts the district’s taxable growth above its base at about $5.2 million the prior year and about $4.9 million now. The records reviewed don’t show how much of the 2022 base came from the land that is now 72927.

District #101: The city’s TIF, and the power plant in it

The Rapid City Catalyst District, Tax Increment Financing District No. 101, was created by the City Council on Sept. 2, 2025.

The council had first approved it July 7, 2025, but a staff report says the process started over because of “a publication error.” The new resolutions, Nos. 2025-100 and 2025-101, replaced the July versions.

The applicant is the city itself. The district covers about 1,813 acres in north Rapid City, roughly between Deadwood Avenue and Elk Vale Road, and from St. Joseph Street north to Country Road.

The original plan totaled $84,126,687:

  • Phase I, $24,580,000: extending 143rd Avenue from Seger Drive to Mall Drive ($7.58 million), traffic signals at 143rd and East Mall Drive and at 143rd and Seger Drive ($1 million each), and $15 million toward the indoor sports fieldhouse, now named the Sanford Health SportsPlex. Sanford Health holds the naming rights under a $10 million, two-decade agreement the City Council approved in August 2026. The city announced the name Nov. 10, 2026.
  • Phase II, $24,000,000: $9 million in water and sewer work “to provide services to a significant industrial client,” and another $15 million for the fieldhouse.
  • Financing costs of $35,506,687 at 7%, plus $40,000 in administrative fees.

What it promised. The staff report cites a Sports Facilities Advisory study estimating $244.5 million in total economic impact from the fieldhouse’s operations over 20 years, and a Miles Partnership study of similar facilities that found up to a 44% increase in annual hotel stays.

It says the fieldhouse will also be funded by private donations, Hotel Business Improvement District No. 2 money and $5 million from the city’s Vision Fund. It says lease revenue, concessions and the hotel district will cover long-term operating costs, “ensuring no burden on property taxpayers.”

The staff report describes the Phase II client as a $400 million private development and says the work “will allow further development along Deadwood Avenue, most of which is outside the proposed TIF boundaries.” Neither the staff report nor the project plan names the client.

Where the money comes from. The repayment schedules list their assumptions. Two stand out:

  • “Black Hills Energy increment is $1,700,000 per year. This figure was provided by Black Hills Energy using the SDDOR formula to calculate increment from a power plant facility.” The schedules start that increment in year 3.
  • “$0 value given to sports complex.” The plan gives the fieldhouse no taxable value.

In the schedule for Phase I alone, the district’s year-3 increment is projected at $1,725,270. Of that, $1,700,000 is the power plant.

Is Lange II inside the district? The district’s legal description includes the parts of Section 22, Township 2 North, Range 7 East, that Black Hills lists as the Lange II site in its 2026–2035 Energy Facility Plan.

The staff report doesn’t name Lange II, but no other Black Hills power plant project is described in the district. The district’s map shows its western edge along Deadwood Avenue North, north of Interstate 90.

Black Hills is separately asking state regulators to let it recover Lange II’s cost from customers. As the Sentinel reported, that request would add about $19.70 a month to a typical household bill as filed, and it is still pending.

The two are separate processes. The surcharge is a utility rate case before the state Public Utilities Commission. The increment is how local property taxes on the plant are allocated once it’s built. The Catalyst plan counts that increment starting in year 3.

Amendment #1. In June 2026, the city approved adding Elevate Rapid City as a second developer in the district. Elevate plans a business park on 128 acres near Mall Drive and Haines Avenue. The amendment:

  • adds $10 million for N. Maple Street, Mall Drive improvements and grading, plus $9,464,314 in financing, for $19,464,314;
  • raises the district’s total eligible costs to $103,591,001;
  • pays Elevate only from the increment its own business park generates, and only after the city’s costs are repaid.

The staff report lists the two parcels’ current land value at $26,800. Elevate projects its development will be worth $120,963,918 by year 20, with 450 direct jobs and 916 total regional jobs, based on a Lightcast economic model cited in the staff report.

The amendment was routed to the Pennington County Commission, the county’s equalization director, Rapid City Area Schools and the West Dakota Water Development District. The staff report records “No comment provided” from each.

Two figures in the amendment’s staff report don’t match. In some places the TIF request is $19,464,314; in others it is $18,600,000, with $8.6 million in financing instead of $9,464,314. The report also lists the district’s certified base at $44,470,500, while its projection tables still start from the earlier $40,245,800 estimate.

Projections vs. the city’s own ledger

Project plans are forecasts. The city’s annual TIF summary, a spreadsheet titled “Rapid City Taxable Valuation – 2025 pay 2026,” shows where each district actually stands.

  • Citywide: It lists 19 active districts with a combined base of $234,765,499, or 2.10% of the city’s $11.16 billion total valuation. Together they produced $6,576,120.41 in tax increment for the current year.
  • District #86 (Black Hills Industrial Center): The district’s value fell from $5,555,097 the prior year to $5,252,961. Its current-year increment was $38,790.26. The original 2022 plan had projected $2,571,210 in increment payments for taxes paid in 2026. The summary still lists the original $78,099,446 maximum, not the lower amended total. The developer’s costs have not yet been certified. The summary lists BankWest as the lender at 6.00% and estimates payoff on Dec. 1, 2041, a year before the district expires.
  • District #101 (Catalyst): The district’s current value, $39,350,508, sits below its certified base of $44,470,500, so it has produced no increment yet. That fits the plan, which doesn’t expect the power plant’s increment until year 3. The summary still lists the pre-amendment maximum of $84,126,687. The lender is the City of Rapid City, at 7.00%.
  • District #80 (Promise Road), projection vs. reality: Its 2017 project plan expected repayment to finish by June 2029. The 2025 summary estimates Dec. 1, 2033, with $3,794,052.33 still owed. The district’s value is $57,275,092, against a $4,087,900 base.
  • District #77 (“Black Hills Energy”): Its value has grown from a $2,623,066 base to $61,917,521. It produced $399,877.63 this year, with $4,261,530 still owed. More on this one below.

District #77: Black Hills Corporation’s own TIF

What it is. A separate, older district that has nothing to do with Lange II. It sits on the opposite side of town.

  • Name: Rushmore Gateway Corridor, according to the city’s history page. The annual summary calls it “BH Energy.”
  • Applicant: Black Hills Corporation. Engineer: Ferber Engineering.
  • Created: April 4, 2016. Expires: April 4, 2036.
  • Financing: Developer-financed at 5.50%, up to a $6,067,965 maximum.

Where it is. Maps filed with a 2017 application for the neighboring Promise Road district put #77 at the southwest corner of Catron Boulevard and Highway 16. That application’s conceptual plan labels the corner “Black Hills Energy Corporate Headquarters.” The Rapid City Journal has reported that the company received the roughly $6 million district in 2016 to build its new headquarters.

Why it owes more than it started with.

  • June 6, 2016: The city certified $3,204,839 in costs.
  • 2016 to 2022: No payments. A 2017 city repayment schedule shows interest at 5.5% added to the balance every six months.
  • End of 2022: The balance had grown to $4,557,713.
  • June 2023: Payments were scheduled to begin.

The reason is overlap. The 2017 boundary map shows #77 partly overlapping an older district, #70, the South Highway 16 sewer district. The same city schedules show #70 paid off in June 2023, the month #77’s payments were set to start. The older district got paid first.

Where it stands. The 2025 summary puts the balance at $4,261,530. The 2017 schedule projected about $715,000 would still be owed in mid-2037, after the district expires.

What changed in 2026

Two rule changes took effect this year.

State law, SB 228. Rapid City rewrote its TIF ordinance (Ordinance 6727) to match 2026’s SB 228, effective July 1. A project plan can now be amended to add up to 25% of its original costs, down from 30%, without resetting the district’s base. Anything larger, or any cost incurred more than five years after a district is created, means the base gets recalculated, which shrinks the increment. Boundaries can’t be changed at all.

The Catalyst amendment added 23.1% to the original plan’s costs, under either threshold.

City policy. The council approved a revised TIF policy June 15, 2026. Among the changes:

  • An independent fiscal feasibility review is now required at least 21 days before the Planning Commission hearing. The reviewer must sign an affidavit of independence from the developer. The developer pays for it.
  • New districts can’t overlap existing ones without a joint city-county resolution, and contiguity rules are tighter.
  • There is no TIF committee in the process. In 2022, District #86 went first to the city’s Tax Increment Finance Project Review Committee, which reviewed it March 1 of that year. The 2026 policy sends applications to the Finance Office, then staff, the Planning Commission and the City Council.

How to read one yourself

Every Rapid City TIF leaves the same paper trail. To check one:

  1. Start with the city’s Tax Increment District History page. It lists every district by number, with its applicant, creation date and status.
  2. Find the staff report. Look for the sections titled Base Valuation, Proposed Costs, Amortization, Percent of Total City Valuation and District Classification.
  3. Read the assumptions under the amortization tables. That’s where a plan says where its money is expected to come from.
  4. Check the county property card. A parcel inside a district shows “TID” in its exemptions field.
  5. Compare the plan to the annual summary. The city’s yearly spreadsheet shows each district’s base, current value, increment collected, lender and interest rate.
  6. Watch for amendments. Under the new rules, an amendment over 25% of the original costs resets the base.

What the documents don’t answer

  • Who is the “significant industrial client” whose $400 million development justified $9 million in Catalyst District water and sewer work?
  • How was the $1.7 million power plant figure calculated, and did Black Hills ask to have Lange II inside the district or simply supply the number when asked?
  • Which figure is right for the Catalyst amendment, $18.6 million or $19.46 million? And was an independent review done before it was approved?
  • What prompted the agricultural reclassification of Tax ID 72927, a parcel inside District #86 that dropped from $2,176,700 to $85,200 in a single assessment year?
  • Why did District #86’s total value drop between the last two assessments, and how much of the drop came from Tax ID 72927?
  • What did District #77, Black Hills Corporation’s Rushmore Gateway Corridor district, pay for, line by line? Its 2016 project plan would say. And if the 2017 projection holds, who absorbs the balance left when the district expires?
  • A Visit Rapid City letter supporting the Catalyst District refers to “Phases 2 and 3,” including partial funding for a new elementary school. The adopted plan has two phases and doesn’t mention a school. Which version was the letter describing?

Sourcing

  • City of Rapid City, Tax Increment District History page: https://www.rcgov.org/departments/community-planning-development/long-range-planning/tax-increment-district-history-1146.html
  • City of Rapid City, “Rapid City Taxable Valuation – 2025 pay 2026” TIF district summary and Active TID Boundaries map (rcgov.org); “Rapid City Taxable Valuation – 2016 pay 2017” summary.
  • Rapid City Journal, “Rapid City looks to tighten up TIF process” (District #77 and the Black Hills Corp. headquarters): https://rapidcityjournal.com/news/local/rapid-city-looks-to-tighten-up-tif-process/article_a9b9b8fc-96a3-52b2-ac4a-da97aaec0ab9.html
  • Promise Road TIF application 17TIF004 (received Aug. 31, 2017): checklist, Exhibits 1–7, vicinity map, boundary map showing TIDs 70, 76 and 77, and conceptual master plan.
  • Promise Road Tax Increment District Project Plan (revised, November 2017); Resolution 2017-100.
  • City of Rapid City, “TID Debt Obligations” repayment schedules for TIDs 70, 76, 77 and Promise Road (prepared Sept. 27 and Nov. 4, 2017; file 17TI004).
  • District #86:
    • Black Hills Industrial Center TIF application (received April 13, 2022), including Exhibit C (costs), Exhibit E (pro forma) and the restated operating agreement
    • Staff Report 22TI002 (April 21, 2022)
    • City Council agenda, May 2, 2022
    • Project Plan, TID #86, with Amendment #1 (25TI011, August 2025)
    • Contract for Construction of Public Improvements by Private Developer for Tax Increment Financing District Number Eighty-Six (developer agreement, L&F item LF091422-02)
    • Legal & Finance Committee agenda, Aug. 27, 2025 (LF082725-06, Resolution 2025-092)
  • District #101:
    • Staff Report 25TI017/25TI018 (Aug. 21, 2025)
    • Rapid City Catalyst District Project Plan
    • Resolutions 2025-100 and 2025-101
    • Visit Rapid City public comment letter (25TI017)
    • Staff Report 26TI006, Amendment #1 (June 4, 2026), with application, project plan and maps
  • City of Rapid City press release, “Officials unveil name for Rapid City’s community sports facility” (Nov. 10, 2026); Sanford Health and Sanford Sports announcements on the naming-rights agreement (Aug. 6 and Aug. 19, 2026).
  • Rapid City Ordinance 6727 (LF052726-04), amending RCMC 3.26.090 to reflect 2026 SB 228.
  • Rapid City Tax Increment Financing Policy, as amended June 15, 2026; Tax Increment Financing Guidelines (2013).
  • Black Hills Power 2026–2035 Energy Facility Plan (Lange II legal description): https://puc.sd.gov/commission/commissionaction/10yearplan/BHE2026.pdf
  • PUC docket EL26-024 (Lange II Phase In Plan Rate).
  • Pennington County Director of Equalization property records, Black Hills Industrial Center, LLC parcels, including Tax IDs 72927 (38-29-200-004), 73237 (38-29-400-002), 75937 and 75938 (accessed Nov. 16, 2026).
  • Percentages and totals calculated by The Rapid City Sentinel from figures in the documents above.

Discover more from THE RAPID CITY SENTINEL

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.