
Rapid City SD – Rapid City has a new data center ordinance on the table, and it’s not the one residents have been commenting on since September.
Ordinance No. 6762, File #26OA008, goes to the Planning Commission at 7:00 a.m. Wednesday, November 25. It comes in two versions, and the City Council will pick one, or neither.
Option 1 prohibits data centers for six months.
Option 2 keeps data centers allowed in industrial zones, with conditions. It has no end date. It stays in place until a later ordinance replaces it.
Option 2 isn’t Ordinance 6746, the data center rules the Planning Commission has continued twice and won’t take up again until January 21, 2027. It’s a separate, shorter ordinance.
It copies some of 6746’s language word for word. It makes one rule much stricter, pushing data centers 3,000 feet from residential zoning.
And it leaves out much of the rest: the public hearing for mid-size facilities, the sound studies, the nighttime noise limit, the vibration ban, and the city’s power to shut off a facility’s water.
Option 2 vs. Ordinance 6746
The 6746 draft sorts data centers into three tiers:
- Micro: up to 10 megawatts and no more than 4,000 gallons of water a day. Permitted with a building permit.
- Large-scale: more than 10 and less than 50 megawatts. Allowed only with a conditional use permit, which goes before the Planning Commission.
- Hyperscale: 50 megawatts or more, or more than 10,000 gallons a day. Prohibited.
Option 2 drops the tiers. Anything below the hyperscale line is treated the same way.
What carries over, nearly word for word
- The hyperscale ban and its 50-megawatt line.
- The evaporative cooling ban, the 9.6-gallons-per-kilowatt fill cap, refill scheduling, and cooling documentation.
- The emergency-only generator rules and EPA Tier 4 standard.
- The “Will Serve” letter and the sewer discharge rules.
What’s stricter in Option 2
- Distance. 3,000 feet, compared with 500 feet for micro and 1,000 feet for large-scale in 6746. In the city’s survey, 82% of respondents said data centers should be more than 3,000 feet from homes.
- Small facilities. Facilities under 10 megawatts would face the 3,000-foot buffer and the fill cap, which 6746 didn’t apply to the micro tier.
What’s looser in Option 2, or left out
- Public review. Under 6746, a 10-to-50-megawatt facility needs a conditional use permit — a Planning Commission hearing, the power to add “any other conditions deemed appropriate,” and an optional neighborhood meeting. Under Option 2, the same facility gets a building permit.
- Sound studies. 6746 requires an acoustical expert’s study before construction and again before occupancy. Option 2 requires none.
- Nighttime noise. 6746 drops the limit to 60 decibels at night and on weekends. Option 2 allows 65 around the clock.
- Low-frequency noise. 6746 limits dB(C), the measure that captures low-frequency hum. Option 2 only limits dB(A).
- Vibration. 6746 bars vibration, oscillation, or infrasound that causes perceptible resonance in buildings or affects the human body. Option 2 doesn’t mention vibration.
- Generator testing. 6746 caps tests at one hour and keeps the noise limit in force during testing. Option 2 has no time cap and lifts the noise limit while testing.
- Water enforcement. 6746 lets the city or utility check actual usage, shut off water above 10,000 gallons a day for large-scale facilities, and deny or limit a project based on available water — with the applicant paying for needed infrastructure. Option 2 asks for an estimate.
- Power planning. 6746 requires large-scale facilities to submit a load ramp schedule and a timeline for any grid upgrades. Option 2 requires the “Will Serve” letter only.
- Expansion. 6746 requires a new review when a data center expands or a second one is added to the same lot. Option 2 has no expansion rule.
- Distance exemption. 6746 measures from any district that allows residential uses, with no exception. Option 2 exempts General Agricultural.
Where it could matter
Two sites already in the public record fall in the 10-to-50-megawatt range — the range where Option 2 replaces a Planning Commission hearing with a building permit.
490 Deadwood Ave. Black Hills Power has a contract, pending before the state Public Utilities Commission since March, to serve “data mining and processing equipment” near its Ben French substation. The customer, CSRE Properties South Dakota, is tied to bitcoin miner CleanSpark, which has told investors its South Dakota site is 15 megawatts. Under 6746, a 15-megawatt data center would need a conditional use permit. Under Option 2, it would need a building permit and the 3,000-foot buffer — if the city counts bitcoin mining as a data center at all.
The Ben French deal: What the public record shows about Black Hills’ bitcoin-mining power contract
Black Hills Industrial Center. One company holds 518.18 acres on the city’s south edge, mostly zoned Heavy Industrial, including the 10-acre site announced for Sequitor Edge. A May 2026 site certification report says Black Hills Energy can serve up to 11 megawatts there without upgrades, and Black Hills Electric Cooperative is planning a substation that could provide up to 20. City staff reports on the park’s subdivisions list industrial, commercial and agricultural zoning along its borders — including the city’s General Agricultural district, the one district Option 2 exempts from the buffer.
Inside the 518-Acre Footprint of Black Hills Industrial Center
The park is also Tax Increment District #86. Neither version of Ordinance 6762 says anything about TIF.
Following the increment: How two Rapid City TIF districts are built to pay for themselves
Whether either site clears Option 2’s 3,000-foot buffer depends on distances the ordinance packet doesn’t map.
Option 2, rule by rule
Data centers stay a permitted use — approved through a building permit, not a public hearing — as long as they meet these conditions:
Hyperscale ban
- Prohibits “hyperscale” data centers in Light Industrial and Heavy Industrial districts.
- Hyperscale means a peak demand of 50 megawatts or more and/or more than 10,000 gallons of water a day, not counting the initial fill and irrigation.
Water and sewer
- Documentation that water and sewer service is available and that the utility can supply it.
- Water sent to the sewer must meet Title 13 of city code and, where it applies, federal wastewater rules (40 CFR Chapter I, Subchapter N).
- An estimate of water use in gallons per minute for an average day, a peak day, and a peak hour.
Power
- A “Will Serve” letter from the electric utility confirming it has the capacity to serve that site and use.
Cooling
- Evaporative cooling is banned. Data centers must use air-cooled, closed-loop, or other non-evaporative systems.
- Closed-loop systems need engineered drawings showing the initial fill doesn’t exceed 9.6 gallons per kilowatt.
- Full refills must be scheduled with the water provider, which can restrict them based on availability and conditions.
- Applicants must document what’s in the cooling system, the maintenance schedule, and how cooling solutions are disposed of.
Generators and air quality
- Generators are for emergencies, testing, maintenance, and commissioning only.
- “Emergency” means the grid can’t supply the facility, or the infrastructure feeding it has failed.
- Generators must meet EPA Tier 4-equivalent emissions standards.
Noise
- 65 dB(A) maximum at the property line, day or night.
- The cap doesn’t apply during power outages or generator testing.
- Testing is limited to 7:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m., Monday through Friday.
Distance from homes
- A data center must be at least 3,000 feet from any zoning district that allows homes as a principal use.
- General Agricultural is exempt.
- The distance is measured from the industrial zoning boundary on the data center’s property to the residential district boundary.
Option 1: The moratorium
- What it does: Prohibits data centers for six months from the date the ordinance takes effect.
- What the staff memo says: It “temporarily prohibits building permits for data centers.”
- What the ordinance says: Neither “pause” nor “moratorium.” The text says data centers “are prohibited.” The city’s press release calls it a “moratorium or ‘pause.’”
- Where it applies: The ordinance only rewrites the Light Industrial section. But under city code, any use permitted in Light Industrial is also permitted in Heavy Industrial — so the moratorium would reach both. Ordinance 6644 spelled out that link when data centers were first added in 2024.
- How it ends: Either when the six months run out, or sooner if a new ordinance — expected to be 6746 — is adopted and takes effect.
- If six months pass with no new ordinance: The current rules come back. Data centers would again be allowed with a building permit and utility paperwork.
One change in both options
Both versions rewrite the definition of a data center to add one sentence: the term “shall not include a facility that is clearly incidental and subordinate to a permitted principal use.”
In plain terms, a server room inside a business whose main use is something else wouldn’t count as a data center.
That sentence isn’t in the current rules, and it isn’t in the 6746 draft.
The two options at a glance
- Data centers allowed in the meantime? Option 1: No. Option 2: Yes, with conditions.
- Hyperscale facilities? Option 1: Prohibited during the moratorium, along with everything else. Option 2: Prohibited.
- Public hearing for mid-size facilities? Option 1: Not applicable. Option 2: No.
- Noise limit? Option 1: None. Option 2: 65 dB(A) at the property line.
- Buffer from residential zoning? Option 1: None. Option 2: 3,000 feet, except General Agricultural.
- How long it lasts? Option 1: Six months, or until a new ordinance replaces it. Option 2: Until a new ordinance replaces it.
- If 6746 stalls? Option 1: Rules revert to the 2024 permit-and-paperwork setup. Option 2: Its rules stay.
How we got here
Ordinance 6644, adopted December 16, 2024, is still the rule.
Under it, a data center is a permitted use in Light Industrial and Heavy Industrial districts. It needs a building permit and paperwork showing the power, water, and sewer providers can serve it.
That’s it.
Ordinance 6746, the city’s rewrite, was introduced September 10. The Planning Commission continued it to November 5, then again to January 21, 2027, to work in public feedback.
That feedback was substantial. According to the staff memo, an October 14 open house and survey drew about 150 responses. The same survey online, open through November 2, drew another 790. The city also received 22 public comment letters.
Council member Laura Armstrong (Ward 5) was the first council member to call for a moratorium on the record. In the final three minutes of the November 10 Public Works Committee meeting, she took a point of personal privilege and asked her colleagues for a “temporary emergency moratorium on all data center projects” until the new rules are adopted. It was a request, not an agenda item, and no vote was taken.
Later that day, Mayor Jason Salamun said on Facebook that he planned to propose a six-month moratorium, with an alternate ordinance adding protections if Council didn’t support a moratorium. “Either way, it’s important that we put guardrails in place,” he wrote.
At the November 16 City Council meeting, data centers drew the most speakers during public comment.
Justin Huntley, the city’s former floodplain manager, urged Council to approve Ordinance 6746 as written or put a moratorium in place quickly.
Former council member Ron Sasso handed out an outline of a ban and asked that it be added to the agenda.
At least six other residents called for a moratorium of at least 12 months or a permanent ban.
Council took no action. Adding a general public comment item to the agenda takes unanimous consent, and no council member made a motion.
On November 20, ten days after Armstrong’s request, both options arrived as a formal proposal. The staff memo says that because of the gap in current rules and the delay on 6746, the Mayor asked for either a temporary moratorium or added protections in the interim.
When to weigh in
Every meeting below includes public comment on agenda items, according to the city.
- Wednesday, November 25, 7:00 a.m. — Zoning Board of Adjustment/Planning Commission, Council Chambers, City Hall
- Wednesday, December 2, 12:30 p.m. — Legal & Finance Committee, Council Chambers
- Monday, December 7, 6:30 p.m. — City Council, first reading, Council Chambers
- Wednesday, December 16, 12:30 p.m. — Legal & Finance Committee, Council Chambers
- Monday, December 21, 6:30 p.m. — City Council, second reading, Council Chambers
Ordinance 6746 returns to the Planning Commission on January 21, 2027.
What to watch
“And,” “or,” or “and/or”?
The staff memo’s summary describes hyperscale as 50 megawatts and more than 10,000 gallons a day. Option 2 says and/or. The 6746 draft says or.
Under “and,” a facility would have to cross both lines to be banned. Under the other two, crossing either one is enough. The ordinance language is what would become law.
The clock
The second reading is December 21. Then the ordinance has to be published before it takes effect.
Until then, Ordinance 6644 applies.
What’s missing from both
Neither option addresses tax increment financing. The one public comment in the agenda packet so far, from a resident, supports a moratorium and argues TIF districts should not be used for data centers. The Black Hills Industrial Center sits inside TID #86.
The fiscal impact section of the agenda summary is blank.
Questions still open
- Would either option apply to an application already filed before the ordinance takes effect?
- Which definition of hyperscale did staff intend — “and,” “or,” or “and/or”?
- Why does Option 2 drop the conditional use permit, sound studies, and vibration limits that 6746 includes?
- Why exempt General Agricultural land from the 3,000-foot buffer, when 6746 didn’t?
- What counts as “clearly incidental and subordinate” — and who decides?
- Does the city’s definition of a data center cover cryptocurrency mining?
- If Council adopts Option 2, does January’s version of 6746 replace it — or could Option 2 become the rules by default?
Sourcing
City of Rapid City Community Development memorandum on File #26OA008 from Current Planning Division Manager Jessica Olson, dated November 20, 2026; Draft Ordinance No. 6762, Option 1 and Option 2;Draft Ordinance No. 6746 (File #26OA00;Ordinance No. 6644 (File #24OA008;26OA008 public comment packet; City of Rapid City agenda item summary for 26OA008; City of Rapid City press release, “Several Upcoming Opportunities for Public Feedback on Data Centers Ordinance,” November 20, 2026; 26OA006 survey results summary (Oct. 14 to Nov. 2, 2026); Council member Laura Armstrong’s statement at the Nov. 10, 2026 Public Works Committee meeting; Mayor Jason Salamun’s Facebook post, Nov. 10, 2026; City of Rapid City livestream of the Nov. 16, 2026 City Council meeting; PUC docket EL26-008; CleanSpark, Inc. investor materials; Quest Site Solutions, Black Hills Industrial Center Certification Report (May 27, 2026); City of Rapid City staff reports 22TI002, 25PL076, 26PL050 and 26PL073.
Related Sentinel coverage: “Ordinance 6746: Rapid City’s Data Center Rules Head Back to Planning Commission Thursday” (Nov. 2, 2026); “Rapid City’s data center rules delayed again, now to January” (Nov. 5, 2026); “Councilor Armstrong Asks Rapid City Council to Pause Data Center Projects Until New Rules Are Adopted” (Nov. 10, 2026; updated with the Mayor’s response); “Rapid City Council Recap: Water Rate Increases Get a Second Look, Disputed Utility Bill Waived 5–4” (Nov. 17, 2026); “The Ben French deal: What the public record shows about Black Hills’ bitcoin-mining power contract”; “Inside the 518-Acre Footprint of Black Hills Industrial Center”; “Following the increment.”
Leave a Reply